American Idol could be headed for an extreme makeover.
Not much publicity has surfaced around the January debut of the talent competition's fifth season and, according to the New York Times, a primary reason for the silence is the possibility that acid-tongued judge Simon Cowell may not be returning to the show to crush the dreams of Idol hopefuls in his signature fashion.
Cowell entered into the reportedly "delicate and hugely expensive renegotiation" process with a major card to play--his massively successful talent competition, The X-Factor, which he created for British television.
Though Cowell signed a contract in 2003 locking him into Idol for an additional three seasons, he only retained the rights to sign the show's winner to his Sony BMG-based record label for the first two of those seasons, meaning the winner of the upcoming season will not have to sign with Cowell.
An associate of Cowell's told the Times that the judge is "not interested in making a star for another label," which may provide him with further incentive to ditch the show and try his luck selling the The X-Factor to a rival network.
However, when it comes to the future of Cowell's Idol career, there's another factor at play. The pessimism purveyor has been sued for copyright infringement by Simon Fuller, whose company 19 Entertainment was the driving force behind both American Idol and its British predecessor, Pop Idol.
At issue was Fuller's allegation that Cowell stole the idea for The X-Factor from the Idol model.
In The X-Factor, competitors are split into three groups: under 25, over 25 and bands. The judges also compete against one another because they each judge the performers in one of the sections. The show currently generates top ratings in Great Britain.
Cowell has referred to Fuller's claims that he stole the concept for X-Factor from Idol as "totally ridiculous."
If the dueling Simons failed to reach a settlement over the weekend, the copyright infringement case was scheduled to kick off Monday. And, if no settlement is secured, Idol as viewers have come to know it could be history.
Representatives for both Fuller and Cowell told the Times that what they most feared was the start of testimony in the case because of what information might come out; for example, opposing opinions on who actually created the Idol concept.
Fox reps told the Times they were afraid of losing Cowell's future services if the trial were to begin.
Should Fuller and Cowell manage to agree to a settlement, Fox has offered Cowell a multimillion-dollar fee to block U.S. distribution of The X-Factor. The proposed deal would grant Fox first rights to acquire Factor, though the network would likely not broadcast the rival series unless Idol was permanently off the air.
Under that deal, Cowell would again command the rights to sign Idol winners to his label and would continue to pull in a hefty salary. His current paycheck is estimated at $8 million a year.
Keeping the Idol franchise intact is of utmost importance to Fox, which plans to charge the record price of $600,000 to $700,000 for 30-second advertising spots during the show.
The network is also mulling the idea of moving the talent quest from its current Tuesday-Wednesday schedule to a Wednesday-Thursday schedule. The half-hour results show that has traditionally aired on Wednesday would possibly be expanded to an hour, were it to air on Thursday, the most watched night of the TV week.
A Fox publicist declined to comment Monday on the Idol predicament.
While the future of Idol remains under discussion, the careers of some of the show's former competitors seem to have caught fire.
Though she didn't win her season of American Idol, Jennifer Hudson had no problem landing her Dream job.
The curvy chanteuse who competed in season three of the talent competition has been cast in a leading role in the upcoming DreamWorks release Dreamgirls, opposite a crew of high-wattage stars including Beyonce Knowles, Jamie Foxx and Eddie Murphy.
Hudson, Knowles and Tony Award-winning stage actress Anika Noni Rose are set to portray the three members of a fictional girl group called the Dreamettes in the film, which is set in the late 1960s and early 1970s and based loosely on the story of the Supremes. Hudson's character, Effie, gets booted once the group becomes successful.
Hudson beat out her former Idol rival and season-three winner Fantasia Barrino for the role--even after Foxx had publicly endorsed Barrino for the part.
Production on the film is expected to commence in January.
Back in April 2004, Hudson's ousting from the third season of Idol created major controversy among her fans, including Elton John, who denounced the show's voters as "incredibly racist."
Though she did not emerge from the talent contest a winner, Hudson has not dropped her musical aspirations. According to her official Website, jenniferhudsonmusic.com, she is in the process of recording her first album and several of her songs are available for download at 99 cents a pop.
Hudson isn't the only Idol loser to stretch her 15 minutes into legitimacy.
Long-haired season-four rocker Constantine Maroulis is set to make a return to the small-screen to star in his own ABC sitcom loosely based on his real life and family relationships. Kelsey Grammer's Grammnet Productions and Paramount Network TV will produce and writer-producer Caryn Lucas (What I Like About You) will pen the series.
"Constantine has just got it," Lucas told the Hollywood Reporter. "None of it needs to be made up. He has a wonderfully funny, rich family life."