Lisa Tucker, 16 years old
After 3 straight weeks on being in the bottom three along with Katherine McPhee and Ace Youn, Lisa, was finally voted off American Idol after singing Because of You, which was originally sang by a former Idol contestant, Kelly Clarkson.
The judges said it was a poor song choice and that she sang it badly. Simon said she made a wrong move singing an award-winning song by a former Idol winner and that she did not make it truly her own.
